<img src="https://certify.alexametrics.com/atrk.gif?account=b2hlr1ah9W20em" style="display:none" height="1" width="1" alt="">
    Login
    Get started

    Isn't it time UK companies paid whistleblowers?

    Published on 06 Dec 2017 by Lynne Callister

    Would it work for your company? Whisper it, but is it time all UK companies offered financial rewards to whistle-blowers?

    Which side of the debate are you on? Should we get paid for blowing the whistle?

    The SEC paid out $37 million to whistle-blowers in 2015 and has $400 million in its Investor Protection Fund to finance future awards.

    Since the whistle-blower program was set up in 2011, it's paid out $111 million. It's certainly been a game-changer - incentivising insiders to blow the whistle on corporate malpractice.

    Let's take a moment to weigh this up and examine the pros and cons...

    The pros of whistle-blowing

    • In critical industries (such as health, nuclear, etc), where the consequences of non-compliance are blowing the whistlegreatest - it's surely a no-brainer
    • Would it speed up reporting and uncover wrongdoing more quickly? 
    • Longer term, with nowhere to hide, would a new era of greater accountability ensue?

    The cons of whistle-blowing

    • Would there be a spike in false reports?
    • Would employees see it as a win/win - a nice little earner plus a chance to get back at their boss or colleague?
    • Longer term, would it lead to dramatic changes in working relationships or loss of trust?

    By offering to financial rewards to whistle-blowers, aren't we asking people to do the right thing but for the wrong reasons?

    Free Whistleblowing Training Presentation

    While in the short-term it may well nudge insiders to disclose malpractice, it may not fundamentally alter behaviour. Surely what we want is for people to speak out and act with integrity, with everyone's best interests at heart - not just their own.

    What are your thoughts on this? Let us know by leaving a comment in the box below.

    Want to find out more about whistle-blowing?

    Find out more about whistle-blowing and how to ensure the protection of whistle-blowers, in our whistle-blowing eLearning module within our Compliance Essentials Course Library.

    Leave a comment

    Tick

    Free Trial: Compliance Essentials

    Skillcast Essentials is our best-selling library and there's a reason for that. Essentials library provides comprehensive coverage of the key compliance / conduct issues that companies in the UK face today.

    Request now

    Biggest GDPR Fines of 2019

    Penalties for breaching the GDPR can reach up to €20 million or 4% of annual global turnover, whichever is highest. We examine the size and reasons for the biggest GDPR fines of 2019. Ever since ...

    Read More
    Highest FCA Fines of 2019

    The FCA issued a record total of £392 million in fines in 2019. In fact, the two largest fines in 2019 were larger than the 2018 totals. We've analysed they key corporate and individual fines in ...

    Read More
    Why a Blended Approach Drives Engagement & Learning Outcomes

    It is critical that you provide training that engages your learners, but should that be face-to-face, e-learning, mentoring or something else? We explain how to blend for success... Whilst compliance ...

    Read More
    Top 10 Compliance Challenges in 2020 and Beyond

    In an increasingly regulated world, organisations are facing greater scrutiny than ever. And in 2020 the focus on compliance is expected to continue to increase. According to Thomson Reuters Cost of ...

    Read More